TY - THES
T1 - Further Characterization, Extension and Application of A Simplified Bonner Sphere Spectrometer
AU - Pinasti, Sita
A2 - Van Hoey, Olivier
A2 - Vanhavere, Filip
A2 - Struelens, Lara
N1 - Score=10
PY - 2018/8/13
Y1 - 2018/8/13
N2 - One disadvantage of a Bonner Sphere Spectrometer (BSS) is the impracticability due to the lengthy process
of measurements as well as the weight issue. Hence, a simplified BSS was developed in the past but having
limited spectrum accuracy at epithermal and high energy region. In addition, the use of cylindrical detector
brings drawback of anisotropic angular response. The overall objective of this thesis was to improve the
performance and features of the simplified BSS by first, utilizing a spherical 3He detector to obtain an
almost flat angular response, and second, by adding two other spheres to refine the reconstructed spectrum
at epithermal and high energy up to 250 MeV. As the final shape of the spectrum also depends on the use of
unfolding methods (i.e., methods for spectrum reconstruction from BSS measurements), we aimed to study
the unfolding performance of the new BSS using four unfolding methods.
This work was divided into several tasks including characterization of energy and angular response of the
current BSS, selection of the new sphere designs, and theoretical performance evaluation of the new BSS
configurations. During the first two stages, MCNPX v2.7 was used as the primary tool for calculation. The
energy response functions were calculated in 115 energy groups from meV up to 252 MeV while the angular
responses were simulated for 13 angles from 0 to 180o. For the new sphere selection, there were 16 design
options in total, consisting of each eight sphere designs for epithermal and high energy regions, respectively.
The new spheres were selected by evaluating the effective rank of response matrices and by performing
unfolding surveys over 45 different spectrums. The use of the unfolding codes (MAXED, GRAVEL, FRUIT,
and Winbugs) was evaluated by simulating three types of fields, including fission, evaporation, and high
energy neutron fields. All codes were fed with the same input, which was a realistic simulated counts data.
The unfolded spectra and the integral quantities (e.g. neutron fluence, ambient dose equivalent) were then
quantified to know the performance of the new configuration and to compare the performance of the codes.
The simplified BSS using the spherical detector has been characterized concerning energy and angular response
by means Monte Carlo calculation. The angular response was nearly isotropic, with minimum 78%
efficiency. The new sphere design evaluation based on both effective rank, unfolding surveys obtained a
similar results suggesting that sphere of diameter 4.5" with 1 mm Cd as well as 10" or 7" with 1 cm W were
suitable for improving the spectrum accuracy at epithermal and high energy regions. Due to the weight consideration,
the 4.5" 1 mm Cd and the 7" 1 cmWspheres were finally selected, with estimated mass of about 1
and 7.5 kg, respectively. After performing an extensive test on three kinds of spectrum, we conclude that the
new BSS configuration, regardless of the use of the unfolding codes, showed its ability to improve the shape
accuracy of the reconstructed spectrum. The expected unfolding performance may vary depending on the
type of the fields, the unfolding technique, and the chosen unfolding parameters. The maximum deviations
in terms of total fluence and ambient dose equivalent for the three kinds of neutron fields were expected
to be within 10%, which is adequate for radiation protection. Though the discrepancy of the reconstructed
spectrum among the different codes was observed, in general, they provide a conservative estimate of the
integral quantities.
AB - One disadvantage of a Bonner Sphere Spectrometer (BSS) is the impracticability due to the lengthy process
of measurements as well as the weight issue. Hence, a simplified BSS was developed in the past but having
limited spectrum accuracy at epithermal and high energy region. In addition, the use of cylindrical detector
brings drawback of anisotropic angular response. The overall objective of this thesis was to improve the
performance and features of the simplified BSS by first, utilizing a spherical 3He detector to obtain an
almost flat angular response, and second, by adding two other spheres to refine the reconstructed spectrum
at epithermal and high energy up to 250 MeV. As the final shape of the spectrum also depends on the use of
unfolding methods (i.e., methods for spectrum reconstruction from BSS measurements), we aimed to study
the unfolding performance of the new BSS using four unfolding methods.
This work was divided into several tasks including characterization of energy and angular response of the
current BSS, selection of the new sphere designs, and theoretical performance evaluation of the new BSS
configurations. During the first two stages, MCNPX v2.7 was used as the primary tool for calculation. The
energy response functions were calculated in 115 energy groups from meV up to 252 MeV while the angular
responses were simulated for 13 angles from 0 to 180o. For the new sphere selection, there were 16 design
options in total, consisting of each eight sphere designs for epithermal and high energy regions, respectively.
The new spheres were selected by evaluating the effective rank of response matrices and by performing
unfolding surveys over 45 different spectrums. The use of the unfolding codes (MAXED, GRAVEL, FRUIT,
and Winbugs) was evaluated by simulating three types of fields, including fission, evaporation, and high
energy neutron fields. All codes were fed with the same input, which was a realistic simulated counts data.
The unfolded spectra and the integral quantities (e.g. neutron fluence, ambient dose equivalent) were then
quantified to know the performance of the new configuration and to compare the performance of the codes.
The simplified BSS using the spherical detector has been characterized concerning energy and angular response
by means Monte Carlo calculation. The angular response was nearly isotropic, with minimum 78%
efficiency. The new sphere design evaluation based on both effective rank, unfolding surveys obtained a
similar results suggesting that sphere of diameter 4.5" with 1 mm Cd as well as 10" or 7" with 1 cm W were
suitable for improving the spectrum accuracy at epithermal and high energy regions. Due to the weight consideration,
the 4.5" 1 mm Cd and the 7" 1 cmWspheres were finally selected, with estimated mass of about 1
and 7.5 kg, respectively. After performing an extensive test on three kinds of spectrum, we conclude that the
new BSS configuration, regardless of the use of the unfolding codes, showed its ability to improve the shape
accuracy of the reconstructed spectrum. The expected unfolding performance may vary depending on the
type of the fields, the unfolding technique, and the chosen unfolding parameters. The maximum deviations
in terms of total fluence and ambient dose equivalent for the three kinds of neutron fields were expected
to be within 10%, which is adequate for radiation protection. Though the discrepancy of the reconstructed
spectrum among the different codes was observed, in general, they provide a conservative estimate of the
integral quantities.
KW - neutron spectrometry
KW - simplified Bonner spheres
KW - unfolding
KW - energy response
KW - angular response
UR - http://ecm.sckcen.be/OTCS/llisapi.dll/open/33013443
M3 - Master's thesis
PB - UMM - Universitätsmedizin Mannheim - Medical faculty Mannheim of Heidelberg University
ER -