TY - JOUR
T1 - The fate of carbon dioxide generated by decomposition of the organic matter in the Boom Clay upon heating at 80 °C
T2 - The buffering role of carbonates and implications for the geological disposal of heat-emitting waste
AU - Honty, Miroslav
AU - Ostertag-Henning, Christian
AU - Koděra, Peter
AU - Frederickx, Lander
AU - Jacops, Elke
AU - Wang, Lian
AU - Salah, Sonia
AU - Sillen, Xavier
N1 - Score=10
Funding Information:
The Boom Clay consists of cyclic alternations between clay rich and silt rich layers reflecting sea-level fluctuations at different scales, from Milankovitch orbital cycles to third-order eustacy cycles (Vandenberghe and Van Echelpoel, 1987). Compared to other argillaceous formations studied in the European context of geological disposal of radioactive waste, the Boom Clay formation contains substantial amounts of organic matter (0.5–3.5 wt% (Zeelmaekers et al., 2015),) of which more than 80% is attributed to the insoluble macromolecular fraction, i.e. kerogen (Deniau et al., 2001, 2004). Rock-Eval analysis revealed TOC values between 0.85 and 4.13 wt% and most of the TOC variance across the Boom Clay formation is correlated to grain size and the thickness of silt/clay layers (Van Geet, 2002). The kerogen type II dominates over type III indicating major contribution of phytoplanktonic material with a low input of terrestrial and bacterial components during its formation (Deniau et al., 2001; Laenen, 1997; Van Geet, 2002). This type II organic matter exhibits a rather high aliphaticity and its chemical structure is mainly based on a macromolecular network of long, normal alkyl chains probably cross-linked by ether bridges located at various positions on the chains. Next to aliphatics, aromatic structures and slightly degraded alcohols and acid moieties were also detected in the Boom Clay kerogen (Deniau et al., 2001). The highly aliphatic character of the Boom Clay kerogen is further supported by remarkably high H/C atomic ratio of 1.27 and HI (hydrogen index expressed in mg HC/g total organic carbon) of 332 mg HC/g TOC (Total Organic Carbon) as documented by (Deniau et al., 2008). The Boom Clay kerogen is also characterized by an especially high O/C atomic ratio (0.27) compared to kerogens from other studied argillaceous rocks (Deniau et al., 2008). A Van Krevelen diagram (Van Krevelen, 1961) used to discriminate various kerogen types and maturity of the organic matter shows that Boom Clay kerogen is located at the onset of the diagenetic evolution stage. This corroborates with the current understanding that Boom Clay was never deeply buried during its geological history thus the organic matter did not experience significant thermal stress (Mertens, 2005). The weak thermal maturation of the Boom Clay is reflected in all molecular maturity parameters, low vitrinite reflectance values (R0 = 0.2–0.83%, (Vandenberghe, 1978), as well as low Tmax data from the Rock Eval analysis (412–418 °C) (Laenen, 1997; Van Geet, 2002). Altogether, low maturity along with the relatively high content of oxygen containing polar components renders the Boom Clay kerogen prone to release liquid and gaseous products even under mild thermal stress, like the one expected from long-term disposal of radioactive waste (Deniau et al., 2001, 2005).
Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 Elsevier Ltd
PY - 2024/2
Y1 - 2024/2
N2 - Short-term and long-term hydrothermal experiments were performed with the bulk Boom Clay (Rupelian, Belgium) involving all its constituents (organic matter, minerals and water) in order to follow CO2 generation primarily formed by organic matter decomposition at 80 °C, the temperature to be reached in the near-field of a repository hosting heat-emitting radioactive waste. The carbon speciation and isotopic data in the sampled gas, liquid and solid phase served as a base for mass balance calculations and evaluation of the fate of the carbon dioxide in the studied system. The maximum CO2 yields are lower (1.9 mmol CO2/kg clay after 21 days) in the short-term hydrothermal tests as compared to the long-term tests (maximum 13.3 mmol CO2/kg clay after 7 years) thus underestimating the total capacity of the clay to generate CO2. This is supported by still continuous generation of the carboxylic acids, important precursors of the released CO2 gas, after 21 days. The stable isotope data (δ13C and δ18O) confirm that CO2 gas released from the Boom Clay is of organic origin. The early released CO2 gas is isotopically lighter (−22.2 to −23.3‰) than the reference δ13C of the CO2 (g) and isotopically heavier than the parent kerogen (−25.5 ‰) in the undisturbed Boom Clay. The early CO2 gas is likely out of isotope equilibrium with either dissolved inorganic carbon or solid carbonates. However, measured and extrapolated δ13C values of CO2 gas indicate the tendency towards isotope equilibrium between CO2 gas and both dissolved and solid inorganic carbon on the longer runs (up to 7 years). The precipitation of the carbonates and recycling of the organic matter derived CO2 in the carbonates is further supported by elemental chemistry and mass balance calculations. Altogether, our results suggest that the CO2 (g) released by Boom Clay organic matter is buffered by the carbonates (both dissolved and solid) present in Boom Clay. Thus, no net accumulation of CO2 (g) from organic matter is expected.
AB - Short-term and long-term hydrothermal experiments were performed with the bulk Boom Clay (Rupelian, Belgium) involving all its constituents (organic matter, minerals and water) in order to follow CO2 generation primarily formed by organic matter decomposition at 80 °C, the temperature to be reached in the near-field of a repository hosting heat-emitting radioactive waste. The carbon speciation and isotopic data in the sampled gas, liquid and solid phase served as a base for mass balance calculations and evaluation of the fate of the carbon dioxide in the studied system. The maximum CO2 yields are lower (1.9 mmol CO2/kg clay after 21 days) in the short-term hydrothermal tests as compared to the long-term tests (maximum 13.3 mmol CO2/kg clay after 7 years) thus underestimating the total capacity of the clay to generate CO2. This is supported by still continuous generation of the carboxylic acids, important precursors of the released CO2 gas, after 21 days. The stable isotope data (δ13C and δ18O) confirm that CO2 gas released from the Boom Clay is of organic origin. The early released CO2 gas is isotopically lighter (−22.2 to −23.3‰) than the reference δ13C of the CO2 (g) and isotopically heavier than the parent kerogen (−25.5 ‰) in the undisturbed Boom Clay. The early CO2 gas is likely out of isotope equilibrium with either dissolved inorganic carbon or solid carbonates. However, measured and extrapolated δ13C values of CO2 gas indicate the tendency towards isotope equilibrium between CO2 gas and both dissolved and solid inorganic carbon on the longer runs (up to 7 years). The precipitation of the carbonates and recycling of the organic matter derived CO2 in the carbonates is further supported by elemental chemistry and mass balance calculations. Altogether, our results suggest that the CO2 (g) released by Boom Clay organic matter is buffered by the carbonates (both dissolved and solid) present in Boom Clay. Thus, no net accumulation of CO2 (g) from organic matter is expected.
KW - Boom clay
KW - Carbon dioxide
KW - Carboxylic acids
KW - Geological disposal
KW - Kerogen
KW - Organic matter
KW - Stable isotopes
KW - Thermal degradation
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85182908653&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2024.105899
DO - 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2024.105899
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85182908653
SN - 0883-2927
VL - 162
JO - Applied Geochemistry
JF - Applied Geochemistry
M1 - 105899
ER -